2-8 Main Street

Crown City Touring- Main Street

2-8 Main Street

Cortland, New York 13045, United States

Created By: Cortland County Historical Society


The first structure on the southwest corner of Main Street and present-day Groton Avenue (at one time named Cortland Street) was called the Lyman Block, a two-story brick structure which is said to have been built around 1816-1817 by Asahel Lyman (1787-1840). Lyman conducted a mercantile business on the spot for about 25 years. By 1855, the same William O. Barnard who owned the Barnard block across the street took possession of the location that would come to be referred to as the “dry goods corner.”

The Samson name comes into the picture some time prior to 1876 when John S. Samson (1806-1890) assumes ownership of the property, followed by his son John Melvin Samson (1835-1929). Unfortunately, tragedy struck the “old Samson block” in January of 1892 when fire broke out in the rear of John H. Day’s grocery. Other businesses present at the time were H.H. Pomeroy’s dry goods store, Sarah Darby’s hair emporium, and George I. Pruden’s photography studio.

In 1896, the new Samson block was erected featuring a stamped iron façade that was replicated in other buildings built during the same period. Nos.2-6 were fitted out for Dwight E. Shepard’s dry goods store with “circular counters, handsome brackets and modern and spacious shelving,” (“Grip’s Historical Souvenir of Cortland,” 1899). Shepard’s took up three floors with the millinery department on the second floor and carpets, upholstery, linoleums, etc. in the basement. At no.8, Mrs. J.T. Davern conducted a highly successful ladies’ furnishing and millinery business. I find it surprising that the two businesses could thrive right next door to each other!

It would be impossible to list each and every business that set up shop in the Samson block, so there are bound to be some that you remember that I don’t mention. But here are some of the names that appeared over the decades (some carried over for decades, but I mention them only once):

1910s- G.H. Wiltsie

1930s- Clifford J. Tanner dry goods, Strong Beauty Shoppe, Mrs. Hester M. Everts millinery

1940s (By this point called the Winters block)- Lee M. Winters women’s wear, Hill Realty Co., Ritz Beauty Salon, Endicott-Johnson Shoe Store

1950s- Fanny Farmers Candy Shop, Kelly & Maher lawyers

1970s- The Cheshire Cat

1980s- Fashions by Giulia, Alfred’s Jewelers

This point of interest is part of the tour: Crown City Touring- Main Street


Leave a Comment



Download the App

Download the PocketSights Tour Guide mobile app to take this self-guided tour on your GPS-enabled mobile device.

iOS Tour Guide Android Tour Guide



Updates and Corrections

Please send change requests to changerequest@pocketsights.com.