Newfield Baptist Church Fire

Finding Fires - Tompkins County

Newfield Baptist Church Fire

Newfield Hamlet, New York 14867, United States

Created By: Ithaca Heritage


Date: February 17, 1917

Location: 105 Bank Street, Newfield

The Newfield Baptist Church was built in 1842 and was one of the oldest churches in the county at the time of the fire. On a Saturday afternoon in 1917, a fire spread from a furnace in the basement. The fire spread slowly throughout the building. Villagers said that if they had been able to respond immediately, the building and its contents could have been saved. Newfield did not have any firefighters or fire engines of their own at the time, so neighbors started a valiant, but unsuccessful, bucket brigade to quell the flames. A call was made to Chief Reilly of the Ithaca Fire Department, but the fire company didn’t arrive until around 4:30pm, by which point the fire had already destroyed most of the building. Newfield residents blamed Reilly and the fire company for their tardiness. Reilly claimed that the call had not reached him until four in the afternoon, almost two hours after the fire started, and the Ithaca Fire Department had no obligation to help fight any fire outside of the Town of Ithaca.

This fire led to Newfield residents to set aside resources for their own fire protection, rather than rely on outside support. Only a month later, a group of men met to organize the first Newfield Fire Company.


This point of interest is part of the tour: Finding Fires - Tompkins County


Leave a Comment



Download the App

Download the PocketSights Tour Guide mobile app to take this self-guided tour on your GPS-enabled mobile device.

iOS Tour Guide Android Tour Guide



Updates and Corrections

Please send change requests to