Our Scenic Spires - Corner of School and Main Streets:

At this intersection, we have in our sights all four of the church spires that are a major feature of the scenic hilltop view I spoke about earlier. As you face the library, to the left is the Trinity Methodist. You may want to capture a photo of its steeple, colorfully decorated with hearts and chevrons. If you are lucky enough to be here in October, you may be in time to experience their annual chicken pie supper. This is an October tradition for churches throughout Vermont. Don’t call them “pot pies”! It’s just “chicken pie” and it’s cooked with biscuits on top rather than pie crust.

Further down School Street you can just get a peek at the First Baptist Church, built in the classic New England Gothic style in 1868, and on the corner opposite the library is the United Church of Christ’s Bethany Church. It was also originally built in 1868 but when it became unstable its red stone blocks were taken down, stone by stone, and then reincorporated into the more modern church that was completed in 1959. The interior includes a chapel with a labyrinth that is open to the public at scheduled times.
Let’s cross the street now for our next stop at the library. Its origin is a story of high drama, greed and redemption, with yet another little ghostly angle thrown on top. There are some benches on the lawn if you’d like to rest your feet while I tell you all about it.

The Unitarian church at this corner is on the site of the first tavern and inn in Montpelier, operated in the 1790s by none other than the ubiquitous Davis family. It became known as the Union House, and several versions of this accommodation literally went up in flames over the years. The last version was across the street where the bank is now, where Sherm Caswell spent his last years, and that eventually burned also.

When the Unitarian Universalists first formed a congregation in Montpelier, they had an arrangement that will probably never be repeated in the modern era. They held their meetings at the State House. This didn’t really suit anyone, though, so a committee of businessmen in the congregation commissioned Boston architect Thomas Silloway to design this church in 1865. It was originally painted a light gray. At some point it was painted all over wedding cake-white, which oddly enough seemed to make it almost invisible. More recently it was repainted in this sage color with white accents and when it was finished it was like it had suddenly stepped from behind a curtain and we were all stunned to realize how beautiful it was.

The Itinerant Organ Maker
If the church is open you should have a peek inside for a better look at the hand-painted windows, the dark walnut pews, and their gloriously restored 1866 pipe organ, built by George Stevens of Cambridge, MA, who was a sort of Johnny Appleseed of organs.

He is said to have installed about 800 of them in churches around the country. This church is also the venue of choice for many classical music concerts. If you are a fan of chamber music, check to see if anything is on during your visit, because for a fraction of what you’d pay in larger cities, you will get to hear world-class musicians in an amazing setting.